Gentle and Lowly · Study questions and Scripture

20. Our Law-ish Hearts, His Lavish Heart

A reading companion to Gentle and Lowly by Dane Ortlund.

Read the assigned section in your copy of the book, then work through the Scripture reflections, questions and practices below. These studies are original Scripture Journey content. They accompany the book and do not replace it.

What to read

20. Our Law-ish Hearts, His Lavish Heart

Chapter 20: Our Law-ish Hearts, His Lavish Heart

Independent reader

Crossway, 2020, ISBN 9781433566134 (the library's recorded edition; the copyright page labels this ISBN trade paperback in its printed-ISBN block and hardcover in the Library of Congress CIP block, and Crossway's product page lists it as hardcover with jacket). Printed contents inspected from the publisher's chapter 1 excerpt PDF: Introduction, 23 numbered chapters, Epilogue, then Acknowledgments and indexes.

Reading outline source

Session 20 · Galatians 3:1-5

Our Law-ish Hearts, His Lavish Heart

Begun by the Spirit, carried on by the Spirit

Book reading: Chapter 20: Our Law-ish Hearts, His Lavish Heart

Paul sounds almost exasperated at the start of Galatians 3: "O foolish Galatians! Who has bewitched you?" These are people who have genuinely believed. They know Jesus was "publicly portrayed as crucified" before their eyes. Yet something has quietly crept in. They are starting to act as if the gospel got them in the door, but now they have to work to stay in the good graces of God.

Ortlund describes this as a stubborn tendency in all of us, which he calls a law-ish heart. Most of us do not announce, "I am earning my salvation." It sounds more like a low hum: I need to do better before I can pray, I should feel worse about this, he is probably disappointed in me this week. This is the hum Paul is hearing in Galatia.

Follow just one thread through the passage. Paul asks two parallel questions. First: "Did you receive the Spirit by works of the law or by hearing with faith?" The Galatians know the answer. Their Christian life began with a gift they received, not a wage they earned. Then comes the sharper one: "Having begun by the Spirit, are you now being perfected by the flesh?" Here is the whole point. The way in and the way forward are the same. Ortlund puts it that the Spirit is both gateway and pathway. The Spirit does not just open the door and then hand you a rulebook for the hallway. He is with you in every step down it.

That changes the picture of what it means to grow. If the Spirit is only the gateway, then after conversion the rest depends on you, and the old hum gets louder. If the Spirit is the pathway too, then growth is more like continuing to receive than finally succeeding. Paul closes the section by pointing again to the one "who supplies the Spirit to you and works miracles among you." The tense is ongoing. He supplies. It is a present generosity, and Paul asks whether that supply comes from your performance or from "hearing with faith." Hearing is a posture of the open hand.

None of this makes effort bad or obedience optional. It means effort flows out of a gift that is still being given, not toward a gift you hope to unlock. This is lavish, not law-ish: a heart that gives freely and keeps giving.

If you tend toward constant self-checking, anxious about whether you have done enough, it can help to talk with a pastor, counselor or trusted friend, since that weight is real and does not need to be carried alone.

Today, listen for the hum in your own head. When you catch it, you are not stuck with it. You can answer Paul's question out loud.

Key idea

In Galatians 3:1-5, Paul says the Spirit who starts the Christian life is also the one who carries it on, so approval is never something you start earning after you begin by grace.

Questions to consider

  1. Where do you hear the quiet hum of earning (for example, "I need to do better before I pray")? What does Paul's question in Galatians 3:3 do to that thought?
  2. If the Spirit is both the gateway and the pathway, what would change about how you approach a hard habit or a dry season?

Journal prompt

Describe one area where you have started acting as if you must perform to keep God pleased. Write out Paul's two questions in Galatians 3:2-3 in your own words and answer them honestly.

Practice

1. Today, notice one moment where you are trying to earn God's approval (a rushed Bible reading, guilt-driven effort, avoiding prayer until you feel worthy). 2. Say one sentence from Galatians 3 aloud, such as "Did you receive the Spirit by works of the law or by hearing with faith?" 3. Answer it with one plain sentence, like "By hearing with faith." 4. Continue what you were doing, now as a receiver.

Keep this book study, journal and ask questions in Scripture Journey.

Open this guide in the app

More from Gentle and Lowly