Session 6 · Luke 12:15-21
What Counts as a Tragedy?
A comfortable, God-free retirement dream versus a life spent for Christ
Book reading: Chapter 3 (Boasting Only in the Cross, the Blazing Center of the Glory of God)
Start with a question Piper presses in this chapter: what do you call a tragedy? Most of us answer fast. A life cut short. A career that never took off. Piper argues that the deepest tragedy looks different. It is a life driven by comfort with God left out, aimed at the retirement dream. He sets that beside two elderly missionary women in Cameroon who spent their last years serving the poor, and he says their deaths were no tragedy.
Jesus tells a story that fits this tension. Read Luke 12:15-21 slowly. He opens with a warning: "Take care, and be on your guard against all covetousness, for one's life does not consist in the abundance of his possessions." Notice the target. It isn't wealth by itself. It's covetousness, the habit of wanting more and expecting more to give you life.
Then comes the parable. The rich man's land "produced plentifully." Nothing is wrong yet. The harvest is a gift. His trouble shows up in how he thinks. He "thought to himself," and the next lines are packed with "I" and "my": "I will do this: I will tear down my barns and build larger ones." He has a good problem, and he consults only himself. God isn't in the planning. Neither is any neighbor. His plan ends with a speech to his own soul: "relax, eat, drink, be merry."
Then God speaks, the only time in the story: "Fool! This night your soul is required of you, and the things you have prepared, whose will they be?" The man isn't called a fool for saving grain. He's a fool because his whole plan assumed he held the clock and that comfort was the point. Jesus sums it up: "So is the one who lays up treasure for himself and is not rich toward God."
This is where Piper's contrast helps. The farmer and the Cameroon missionaries aren't separated by how much sits in the barn. The question is where the treasure is and who the soul is for. Piper isn't saying rest is sinful or that planning ahead is wrong. He's warning about a life whose finish line is ease without God.
Be honest about your own picture of "someday." Most of us carry one: a stretch of life when the work is done, the money is fine, and the pressure is off. Don't throw that picture out. Look inside it. Is God in it? Are other people in it? If someone watched your plans, would they guess you believe the parable?
Key idea
The tragedy Jesus warns about isn't a short or hard life but a comfortable one planned with no thought of God or of being rich toward him.
Questions to consider
- When you hear the word tragedy, what picture comes to mind first? How does Piper's idea of a God-free, comfort-driven life challenge or confirm that picture?
- Read the parable again and count the times the rich man says "I" or "my." Where do you hear your own planning voice in his?
Journal prompt
Describe your picture of a good ending to your working years or your life in a few sentences. Then circle anything in it that would look the same whether or not God existed. What would it look like to be rich toward God in that same picture?
Practice
1. Set a timer for 10 minutes and write out your "someday" plan in plain sentences. 2. Underline every line that is only about comfort or security. 3. Next to each underlined line, write one way you could be rich toward God in that same space, such as giving, serving, or praying. 4. Pick one of those and put it on your calendar this month.