1 Samuel 15:1-23 · 5-day study

The Almost King

Going deeper on Robby Gallaty's sermon at Long Hollow (Hendersonville, TN).

Week of Aug 9, 2026

The big idea

Saul's partial obedience was really disobedience, and God wants a clean heart and a quick yes from us, not a tidy look and religious activity to cover what we're hiding.

Day 1 · Free1 Samuel 15:1-23

First Impressions

Saul won the battle. So what's that noise?

Picture the scene. Saul is Israel's first king. He's tall, he looks the part, and he's just been handed a big assignment. The prophet Samuel tells him to 'listen now to the message from the Lord' (1 Samuel 15:1), and then lays out a clear job: stop the Amalekites, a people who attacked Israel back when they were tired and weak after leaving Egypt. Saul gathers an army and goes. The instructions weren't vague. Nothing was to be kept for himself or his soldiers. And here's the part that's easy to miss: he wins. By the time he heads home, the scoreboard looks great. There's a victory, there's a crowd, and Saul even stops to put up a monument along the way. If you'd been watching from the sidelines that day, you would have called it a success.

Then Samuel shows up, and his first question might be one of the best lines in the whole Bible: 'What then is this bleating of sheep in my ears?' (verse 14). In plain English, 'What's that noise?' Saul had just told him, 'I have carried out the Lord's instructions' (verse 13). But the sheep and cattle Saul was supposed to leave alone were standing right there, making noise. Everybody in earshot could hear it, except maybe Saul. They were proof that 'mission accomplished' was really 'mission mostly accomplished.' That's what makes this story so sticky. Saul isn't a villain who stomped up and told God no. He said yes. He did most of it. He even had a religious-sounding reason for the rest: the best animals, he said, were being saved to worship God.

That's the tricky thing about 'almost.' From the inside, it feels a lot like obeying. It sounds right, it looks right, and it leaves a little bit of noise that never quite goes away. If Sunday had you thinking, 'Ouch, that's me,' take a breath. This week isn't about beating ourselves up. And God isn't standing there with a clipboard, hoping to catch you. He's a Father who wants all of you, not just the parts that are easy to hand over. So this week is about taking an honest look at a story that's three thousand years old and still asking a simple question: where are we close, but not all the way? Over the next few days we'll slow down and dig into what's really happening in this chapter, and what God might be inviting you into. For today, just read 1 Samuel 15:1-23 once, slowly. Notice where you relate to Saul. Not where you'd like to relate. Where you actually do.

Sit with this

  1. 1Which part of Saul's story felt a little too familiar to you, and why do you think that is?

Journal prompt

Think of one thing you believe God has asked you to do that you've done 'mostly.' Write down what the finished part looks like and what the missing part looks like. Be as specific as you can.

Days 2–5 are in the app

Carry Robby Gallaty's sermon through the whole week.

  1. 2

    Look Closer

    Why God's heart breaks over a king who 'almost' followed

  2. 3

    What It Meant Then

    Who the Amalekites were, and what 'listen' really meant

  3. 4

    The Hard Question

    What's your 'but I did this other good thing'?

  4. 5

    Carry It Forward

    The thread that runs from the Garden to the cross

Start this study free

Free while in beta. Journal and ask questions as you go.

Where the passage connects

  • 1 Samuel 15:1-23

    God told Saul to wipe out the Amalekites, Saul kept the king and the best animals and called it worship, and Samuel answered that obeying God beats offering him sacrifices.

  • Genesis 6:5-6

    Long before Saul, God was said to regret and grieve over human sin, which shows that his sorrow comes from love and not from a change of plan.

  • Ephesians 4:30

    Paul tells believers not to grieve the Holy Spirit, so our sin hurts the heart of a God who loves us and does more than break a rule.

  • Psalm 51

    David, confronted by Nathan over Bathsheba, owned his sin before God, and his prayer shows that brokenness can lead to breakthrough, the opposite of Saul's excuses.

“Whenever you hear the word listen, it doesn't mean audio, hearing. It means action.”

Robby Gallaty

“God is not looking for extravagant worship if he doesn't have from us daily obedience.”

Robby Gallaty

Get the Long Hollow study every Monday

One email. Sunday's message, the points, and the verses. Free.

Unsubscribe any time. We never share your address.

More from Long Hollow

All Long Hollow studies →

This study is an original devotional inspired by Robby Gallaty's message “To Obey or Not to Obey, That is the Question | Robby Gallaty | 1 Samuel 15” at Long Hollow. Watch the original sermon.