John 20:24-29 · 5-day study

When Doubt Meets the Risen Jesus

Going deeper on Joey Presutti's sermon at Gather Church.

Week of Apr 5, 2026

Day 1 · FreeJohn 20:24-29

First Impressions

Meeting Thomas in the middle of his mess

Thomas gets a bad rap. We call him "Doubting Thomas" like it's his official title. But here's what I love about this story — Thomas is just being honest. His best friend was brutally executed three days ago. The other disciples are telling him they saw Jesus alive, and Thomas is like, "Yeah, I'm going to need more than your word on this one."

Can we just acknowledge how human that is? When life falls apart, when the unthinkable happens, when everything you believed in seems to crumble — of course you have questions. Of course you need proof. Thomas wasn't being difficult. He was being real.

What strikes me most about this passage is what Jesus does next. Eight days pass. Thomas is still wrestling with it all. And then Jesus shows up. Not with a lecture. Not with disappointment. He walks into that locked room and the first words out of his mouth are: "Peace be with you." Then he turns to Thomas and essentially says, "You want proof? Here it is. Touch my hands. Touch my side. Stop doubting and believe."

Jesus didn't avoid Thomas. He didn't write him off as the problem disciple. He came back specifically for him. He met Thomas exactly where he was — in the middle of his doubt, his questions, his need for something solid to hold onto. And that's what Easter is really about. It's not about having perfect faith or never asking hard questions. It's about a God who shows up in our locked rooms, in our darkest doubts, and says, "Peace be with you. I'm here. Let's work through this together."

Maybe you're more like Thomas than you want to admit. Maybe you've been hurt by church, disappointed by circumstances, or you're just not sure what you believe anymore. That's okay. Jesus isn't afraid of your questions. He's not intimidated by your doubt. He's actually inviting you to bring all of it to him — the mess, the confusion, the skepticism — because he knows that real faith is built in those honest moments.

Sit with this

  1. 1What doubts or questions about God have you been afraid to say out loud?

Journal prompt

Write about a time when you felt like God slammed the door in your face. What were you going through? What questions did you have? Looking back now, where do you think Jesus was in that moment?

Days 2–5 are in the app

Carry Joey Presutti's sermon through the whole week.

  1. 2

    Look Closer

    The kind of belief Jesus is actually after

  2. 3

    What It Meant Then

    Why Thomas needed to see what he saw

  3. 4

    The Hard Question

    What are you really waiting for?

  4. 5

    Carry It Forward

    Living like the tomb is empty

Start this study free

Free while in beta. Journal and ask questions as you go.

“There's never been a moment where death was defeated. There's never been a time where sin met its match. There's never been a victory quite so decisive.”

Joey Presutti

“If he lives, then you have to do something, even when it seems impossible to do.”

Joey Presutti

Get the Gather Church study every Monday

One email. Sunday's message, the points, and the verses. Free.

Unsubscribe any time. We never share your address.

More from Gather Church

All Gather Church studies →

This study is an original devotional inspired by Joey Presutti's message “I Believe” at Gather Church.