Matthew 23:1-12 · 5-day study

Beyond the Mask

Going deeper on Joby Martin's sermon at Church of Eleven22 (Jacksonville, FL).

Week of Sep 6, 2026

The big idea

Jesus is harder on people who fake closeness to God than on people who know they're far from Him, because empty religious performance blocks others from the kingdom instead of inviting them in.

Day 1 · FreeMatthew 23:1-12

First Impressions

What happens when religion looks perfect on the outside but is empty inside?

Picture this: Jesus is in the temple courts, and it's His last public sermon before He heads to the cross. He's not talking to a small group. He's standing in front of huge crowds, His own disciples, and the very religious leaders who are about to have Him killed. And in front of everybody, He does something surprising. He doesn't attack their theology. He doesn't argue with their Bible knowledge. He goes after their hearts.

Jesus tells the crowd, "The scribes and the Pharisees sit on Moses' seat... so do and observe whatever they tell you, but not the works they do." Read that twice. Jesus just told a massive crowd, "Listen to what these guys teach, because it's still God's truth. But don't copy their lives." That's a strange thing to say about the most respected religious leaders in the country. These weren't con men running a scam. They were the Bible scholars, the ones everybody assumed were the closest people to God. And Jesus stands up and says their actions don't match their words.

Here's what stood out to me reading through this: Jesus isn't mainly upset that they broke rules. He's upset that they built an entire religious life around looking right instead of being right with God. They had the outfits, the titles, the best seats, and the reputation. But underneath all of that, something was missing — real, honest love for God that actually shows up in how you treat people.

This is where the idea of "religion versus redemption" comes in. Religion can turn into a checklist: show up, say the right things, follow the rules, look the part. Redemption is different. It's what happens when God actually changes your heart, and everything else flows out from there. You can have all the religious activity in the world and still be miles away from God on the inside. That should make us stop for a second.

Before you start thinking about that one person you know who fits this description perfectly, let's be honest with ourselves first. Most of us have had seasons where we sang the songs, checked the boxes, and looked good on a Sunday morning, but our hearts weren't really in it. Maybe that's happening right now. That's not meant to make you feel guilty — it's meant to be an invitation. Jesus isn't after your performance. He's after your heart. And honestly, that's really good news, because it means you don't have to fake it anymore.

Sit with this

  1. 1When you think about your faith this week, has it felt more like something you're doing for God, or something that's flowing out of loving Him? Be honest with yourself.

Journal prompt

Write about one thing you do regularly for your faith — church, serving, prayer, whatever it is. Then ask yourself honestly: is this coming from love for God, or from habit, guilt, or wanting to look a certain way to other people?

Days 2–5 are in the app

Carry Joby Martin's sermon through the whole week.

  1. 2

    Look Closer

    The word 'hypocrite' meant something very specific — and it's not just lying.

  2. 3

    What It Meant Then

    Why 'Moses' seat' mattered, and what those fancy religious clothes were actually for.

  3. 4

    The Hard Question

    It's easy to spot a Pharisee. It's a lot harder to admit you might be one.

  4. 5

    Carry It Forward

    You have something the Pharisees never figured out how to use — the keys.

Start this study free

Free while in beta. Journal and ask questions as you go.

Where the passage connects

  • Matthew 23:1-12

    This is Jesus' last public confrontation with the Pharisees, where He names four heart problems behind their religion before ever getting to the specific woes.

  • Matthew 15:7-8 (quoting Isaiah)

    Jesus uses this line to show that lip-service worship can exist right alongside a heart that has drifted far from God.

  • Revelation 2:1-5

    The church at Ephesus was doing almost everything right on paper, yet Jesus warned He would remove His presence if they didn't return to loving Him first.

  • Matthew 16:18-19

    Jesus hands Peter the keys of the kingdom right after his confession of faith, setting up the contrast with the Pharisees who used their position to lock people out.

  • 1 Peter 2:9

    Peter later tells ordinary believers they are a royal priesthood, meaning the door-opening authority the Pharisees hoarded now belongs to every Christian.

“Way more is caught than taught. That's also true in discipleship.”

Pastor Joby Martin

“The reason you have the job you have is because God needed a servant with the keys to the Kingdom in that place.”

Pastor Matt Carter

Get the Church of Eleven22 study every Monday

One email. Sunday's message, the points, and the verses. Free.

Unsubscribe any time. We never share your address.

More from Church of Eleven22

All Church of Eleven22 studies →

This study is an original devotional inspired by Joby Martin's message “Condition of the Heart - Religion to Redemption - Matthew S6E5” at Church of Eleven22. Watch the original sermon.